Stereotypical female behavior, as modeled by the characters, is seen as a negative for girls—but good for boys
If you’re looking for further evidence that the constant deluge of princess ephemera being aimed directly at your daughters has a effect, a new study out of Brigham Young University will confirm your dark fears. But then it gets complicated. Because it affects your sons, too.
As KJ Dell’Antonia writes this week in the New York Times, a study of nearly two hundred boys and girls aged 5 to 6 revealed that “higher princess involvement (through toys, products and media consumption) over the course of a year was associated with higher levels of female gender-stereotypical behavior at the end of the study.” But for girls, that stereotypical behavior — “quiet play, pretend cooking and cleaning, and avoiding risks, getting dirty or trying new things” — has more negative, “potentially problematic” associations, while for boys, “becoming more feminine is becoming more well-rounded.” How’s that for a stacked deck, am I right, ladies?
The study, with the says-it-all-name “Pretty as a Princess: Longitudinal Effects of Engagement With Disney Princesses on Gender Stereotypes, Body Esteem, and Prosocial Behavior in Children,” notes that “30 studies found that television viewing can develop and reinforce children’s attitudes regarding gender stereotypes,” unsurprising given Disney’s three billion dollar a year in princess profits.
Five years ago, author Peggy Orenstein explored the effects of princess culture in her “Cinderella Ate My Daughter,” and what happens when girls are confined to “the pink box.” As she told Salon at the time, “Now you’re already a princess while you’re still in the womb. And then you hear for years, ‘You’re so pretty,’ until suddenly you’re not pretty enough.”
To be clear, the notion that typically feminine behaviors and attitudes are a detriment to girls is one that needs a skeptical examination. But I’m not sure Catherine Connors —founder of Demeter Media, but the former head of content at Disney Interactive for Women and Family — is the world’s most unbiased authority. Speaking with the Times, Connors said this week that “the idea of femininity being encouraged in girls” as problematic is “a manifestation of institutional and cultural sexism.” And sure, you can absolutely rock a tiara and run the world. Pink is a power color, too.
Yet I question Connors’ assertion that “Snow White and Cinderella are active. They’re just not necessarily active in masculine ways. We see Cinderella being kind as somehow less noble than going out after a dragon.” Uhhhh, no offense to princesses, but Snow White is literally unconscious for a key portion of her narrative. Cinderella is rescued from a life of forced domestic servitude by a prince and a FANCY SHOE. Makes one wonder how Connors can, with a straight face, ponder that “We wring our hands about girls being snookered by the princess narrative, but we don’t worry about boys being confused about their future as superheroes.” While princesses like Mulan and Merida show that girls can be beautiful and brave, the newest Disney princess study shows exactly why parents still feel the need for all that hand-wringing.
more recommended stories
- Massachusetts – MPP
Defending Question 4: The work continues.
- Reviving The War On Drugs Will Further Harm Police-Community Relations
The United States has been waging.
- Senators Defy Jeff Sessions And Vote To Extend Medical Marijuana Protections
A congressional committee voted Thursday to.
- President Trump’s Transgender Military Ban Is an Affront to the Core Tenets of the US Military
This morning, on the 69th anniversary.
- Grande Produce Issues Voluntary Recall of Limited Quantity of Papaya â€œCaribeÃ±aâ€� Due to Potential Health Risk
Salmonella is an organism that can.
- Hy-Vee, Inc. Issues Allergy Alert on Undeclared Soy in Hy-Vee Brand Pizzas
Eight varieties of Hy-Vee pizzas are.
- FDA Investigates Multiple Salmonella Outbreak Strains Linked to Papayas
Page Last Updated: 07/25/2017 Note: If.
- 08/04/17 International March to Close all Slaughterhouses San Francisco
http://2.gravatar.com/avatar/2254a10418ab6809af6a74370620d6fa?s=96&d=identicon&r=G http://www.wcuw.org/vegannation/V.N.08.04.17.MarchToCloseSlaughterhouses.SF.mp3 VEGAN NATION Radio 1/2.
- The Idaho Foodbank Recalls Coconut Beverage, Broccoli Cheddar Soup, Eggs, and Cheese Product Because Of Possible Health Risk
The Idaho Foodbank is recalling approximately.
- Bhu Foods Voluntarily Recalls Protein Bars for Possible Health Risk
Hudson Valley Foods, Inc. of Highland,.